TY - JOUR
T1 - The performance of active spectral reflectance sensors as influenced by measuring distance, device temperature and light intensity
AU - Kipp, Sebastian
AU - Mistele, Bodo
AU - Schmidhalter, Urs
N1 - Funding Information:
This research was funded by DFG (German Research Foundation) project Nr. SCHM14563-1 and supported by the BMBF funded projects FKZ 0330800A and CROP.SENSE.net 031553 0C.
PY - 2014/1
Y1 - 2014/1
N2 - Spectral remote sensing is widely used for land-use management, agriculture, and crop management. Spectral sensors are most frequently adopted for site-specific fertiliser applications and, increasingly, for precision phenotyping. With the use of active sensors in the field, it is inevitable that they will be used under varying ambient conditions and with varying crop distances, but it remains unclear how these factors affect the active sensors' performance. This study was conducted to determine whether changes in light intensity, ambient temperature, and measuring distance influence the accuracy of the spectral reading from three different active sensors (NTech GreenSeeker RT100, Holland Scientific CropCircle ACS 470, YARA N-Sensor ALS). The distance between sensor and target surface was the major factor to be considered, depending on the sensor type. Optimised measuring distances to crop canopies that enable stable sensor outputs were determined from 10 to 200. cm sensor-object distance (GreenSeeker: 70-140. cm, CropCircle: 30-200. cm and ALS N-Sensor: 50-200. cm) and compared to manufacturer's recommendations for correct use of the sensors. In addition, the device temperature had variable results depending on sensor and spectral index. In contrast, varying light conditions, including nocturnal usage, hardly affected the performance of the sensors in agreement with the manufacturers' claims that sensor performance is independent of ambient light conditions. Given the preliminary nature of these investigations, further research into optimising the sensor performance with respect to the measuring distance and the device's temperature are needed to improve the application of this technology under field conditions.
AB - Spectral remote sensing is widely used for land-use management, agriculture, and crop management. Spectral sensors are most frequently adopted for site-specific fertiliser applications and, increasingly, for precision phenotyping. With the use of active sensors in the field, it is inevitable that they will be used under varying ambient conditions and with varying crop distances, but it remains unclear how these factors affect the active sensors' performance. This study was conducted to determine whether changes in light intensity, ambient temperature, and measuring distance influence the accuracy of the spectral reading from three different active sensors (NTech GreenSeeker RT100, Holland Scientific CropCircle ACS 470, YARA N-Sensor ALS). The distance between sensor and target surface was the major factor to be considered, depending on the sensor type. Optimised measuring distances to crop canopies that enable stable sensor outputs were determined from 10 to 200. cm sensor-object distance (GreenSeeker: 70-140. cm, CropCircle: 30-200. cm and ALS N-Sensor: 50-200. cm) and compared to manufacturer's recommendations for correct use of the sensors. In addition, the device temperature had variable results depending on sensor and spectral index. In contrast, varying light conditions, including nocturnal usage, hardly affected the performance of the sensors in agreement with the manufacturers' claims that sensor performance is independent of ambient light conditions. Given the preliminary nature of these investigations, further research into optimising the sensor performance with respect to the measuring distance and the device's temperature are needed to improve the application of this technology under field conditions.
KW - Fertilisation
KW - Phenomics
KW - Precision farming
KW - Precision phenotyping
KW - Site specific management
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84887566023&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.compag.2013.10.007
DO - 10.1016/j.compag.2013.10.007
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:84887566023
SN - 0168-1699
VL - 100
SP - 24
EP - 33
JO - Computers and Electronics in Agriculture
JF - Computers and Electronics in Agriculture
ER -