Differential treatment in acute upper cervical spine injuries: A critical review of a single-institution series

BACKGROUND: A single-institution series of injuries of the upper cervical spine are analyzed retrospectively and the literature relevant to the topic is reviewed. METHODS: Seventy patients (34 female, 36 male, mean age 47 years) were admitted during a 5-year period for injuries of the upper cervical spine. Sixty-five were followed for a mean time of 18 months. Three isolated ligamentous instabilities, 6 isolated C1 fractures, 3 complex C2 fractures, 10 combined C1/C2, and 48 C2 fractures (17 hangman's, 31 odontoid) were diagnosed. Twenty-nine patients were treated conservatively and for 41 patients surgery was the primary treatment. Twenty-three ventral odontoid screw fixations, 8 ventral platings and 10 dorsal stabilizations were performed. Stability was evaluated using flexion-extension radiography. Pain levels and neurological outcome were assessed. RESULTS: Operative mortality and neurological morbidity were 0%. Two wound infections and 3 instabilities (17%) in odontoid Type II fractures primarily treated with ventral odontoid screw fixation needed dorsal restabilization. During follow-up examinations the neurological status of three patients was improved. In 62 patients preoperative status was attained. Six patients evaluated their pain as severe, two as disabling. CONCLUSIONS: Candidates for surgery as the primary treatment include those with isolated ligamentous instabilities, Type III hangman's fractures and Type II odontoid fractures with dislocation more than 5 mm. In combined C1/C2 fractures the axis fracture dictates the treatment strategy. Patients who undergo dorsal procedures and have involvement of C1 have a greater chance of developing persistent pain. (C) 2000 by Elsevier Science Inc.